Mechanical teardown

Automatic diver's watch, 3 hands + date (generic, 21,600 bph)

A self-winding watch that stores the wearer's arm motion in a coiled spring and releases it through a gear train at exactly six beats per second, kept honest by a balance wheel and hairspring, inside a 200 m water-resistant steel case.
Mechanical wristwatchUnbranded mass-market exampleillustrative design$295.00500,000 / yr (assumed)
112
parts (49 line items)
75
theoretical minimum parts
26.1 %
DFA index (best practice > 25 %)
864 s
manual assembly time
$47.44
should-cost, 16 % of price
7.4/10
repairability

01What was examined

02Requirements and function structure

User needEngineering metricHow the design meets it
Keeps good timeRate -20 / +40 s/day across positions; isochronism within 10 s/day from full wind to 24 h21,600 bph balance with an index regulator for adjustment; the Fe-Ni self-compensating hairspring keeps the rate stable with temperature
Runs over a weekend off the wristPower reserve >= 40 hBarrel turns once per 8 h (80/10 into the centre pinion); 5.1 turns of mainspring give about 41 h
Winds itselfFull wind after about 8 h of normal wear3 g off-centre rotor on a ball bearing; pawl lever rectifies both rotation directions into ratchet motion
Can be dived with200 m water resistance (ISO 6425 style test); readable in the darkScrew-down crown and caseback with radial gaskets; compressed crystal gasket; lume on hands and indices; unidirectional bezel
Survives knocksRuns after a 1 m drop onto hardwood (ISO 1413 style)Spring-mounted shock settings on both balance pivots
Survives a phone or bag claspRate change < 30 s/day after 4,800 A/m (ISO 764)Fe-Ni hairspring meets the minimum; a silicon hairspring would make this a non-issue (see opportunities)
  • Store energy
    • Wind automatically from wrist motion M28, M29
    • Wind manually with the crown C08, M20, M21, M23, M24
    • Store and release torque M07, M08, M09
  • Divide time
    • Transmit and step down (barrel to escape wheel, ratio 1:5760) M10, M11, M12, M13
    • Release one tooth per two beats M14
    • Oscillate at 3 Hz M15, M16, M17, M18
  • Display time and date D01, D03, M25, D04, M26
    • Set hands and date M20, M21, M22
  • Locate and support M01, M02, M03, M04, M05, M06, M19, M27
  • Protect from water, dust and knocks C01, C04, C05, C06, C07, C08, C09
  • Attach to the wrist S01, S02, S03

03Bill of materials

IDPartQtySubassemblyMaterialProcessMassCostNecessary?
C01Case middle with lugs1Case316L stainlesscnc milling48 g$9.00yes
C02Unidirectional bezel with anodized insert1Case316L stainlesscnc turning7.0 g$2.20yes
C03Bezel click spring (120 clicks)1Casespring steelstamping0.10 g$0.01yes
C04Sapphire crystal, AR coated inside1Casesapphirepurchased2.5 g$4.50yes
C05Crystal gasket (compressed)1Caserubberpurchased0.10 g$0.05yes
C06Screw-down caseback1Case316L stainlesscnc turning14 g$3.00yes
C07Caseback gasket1Caserubberpurchased0.10 g$0.03yes
C08Screw-down crown with tube and 2 gaskets1Case316L stainlesspurchased1.5 g$1.60yes
C09Movement holder ring1CasePA66injection molding0.80 g$0.04no
C10Casing clamps with screws2Casesteelpurchased0.10 g$0.06no
D01Dial, printed, applied lumed indices1Dial and handsbrasspurchased1.2 g$2.00yes
D03Hands (hour, minute, seconds) with lume3Dial and handsbrasspurchased0.18 g$1.05yes
D04Date disc, 31 days1Dial and handsbrassstamping0.30 g$0.30yes
F02Dial-side screws3Keyless and motion workssteelpurchased0.03 g$0.03no
M20Winding stem1Keyless and motion worksalloy steelscrew machining0.10 g$0.33yes
M21Sliding pinion (clutch) and winding pinion2Keyless and motion workssteelpurchased0.10 g$0.24yes
M22Setting lever, yoke and yoke spring3Keyless and motion workssteelstamping0.15 g$0.24yes
M23Crown wheel and ratchet wheel2Keyless and motion workssteelstamping0.30 g$0.24yes
M24Click and click spring2Keyless and motion workssteelstamping0.04 g$0.10yes
M25Cannon pinion, minute wheel, hour wheel3Keyless and motion worksbrasspurchased0.15 g$0.30yes
M26Date driving wheel, date jumper and spring3Keyless and motion workssteelstamping0.15 g$0.30yes
M07Barrel drum (80 T) and cover2Movement energybrasspurchased0.50 g$0.50yes
M08Mainspring with slipping bridle1Movement energyCo-Ni spring alloypurchased0.40 g$0.60yes
M09Barrel arbor1Movement energyalloy steelscrew machining0.08 g$0.42yes
M28Oscillating weight (rotor) on ball bearing1Movement energybrasspurchased3.0 g$1.20yes
M29Pawl lever with eccentric and transmission wheels3Movement energysteelstamping0.15 g$0.45yes
F01Movement screws (bridges, cock, rotor, plates)16Movement framesteelpurchased0.16 g$0.16no
M01Main plate (pillar plate)1Movement framebrasscnc milling3.5 g$3.00yes
M02Barrel bridge1Movement framebrasscnc milling1.2 g$1.20yes
M03Train wheel bridge1Movement framebrasscnc milling0.80 g$1.00yes
M04Balance cock1Movement framebrasscnc milling0.40 g$0.80yes
M05Pallet bridge1Movement framebrasscnc milling0.20 g$0.50yes
M06Automatic device bridge1Movement framebrasscnc milling1.0 g$1.00yes
M19Jewels pressed into plate and bridges18Movement framesynthetic rubypurchased0.05 g$0.36yes
M27Date ring holding plate1Movement framebrassstamping0.40 g$0.03yes
M14Pallet fork with 2 ruby pallet stones1Movement regulatorsteelpurchased0.02 g$0.40yes
M15Balance wheel with staff, roller and impulse jewel1Movement regulatorbrasspurchased0.30 g$0.80yes
M16Hairspring with collet and stud1Movement regulatorFe-Ni alloypurchased0.01 g$1.20yes
M17Regulator index1Movement regulatorsteelstamping0.05 g$0.10yes
M18Shock settings (spring, cap and hole jewels)2Movement regulatorspring steelpurchased0.02 g$0.50yes
P01Lubrication points (oils and greases)12Movement regulatoroilpurchased0.000 g$0.05no
P02Regulation on a timegrapher, demagnetise1Movement regulatorpurchased0.000 g$0.00no
M10Centre wheel (64 T) and pinion (10)1Movement trainbrasspurchased0.20 g$0.35yes
M11Third wheel (75 T) and pinion (8)1Movement trainbrasspurchased0.08 g$0.25yes
M12Fourth (seconds) wheel (84 T) and pinion (10)1Movement trainbrasspurchased0.07 g$0.25yes
M13Escape wheel (15 T) and pinion (7)1Movement trainsteelpurchased0.02 g$0.30yes
S01FKM rubber strap halves2Straprubberpurchased22 g$4.00yes
S02Spring bars2Strap316L stainlesspurchased0.80 g$0.16no
S03Buckle with pin1Strap316L stainlesspurchased4.0 g$0.80yes

04Materials and processes

Mass by material

316l stainless 75 g (65 %)rubber 22 g (19 %)brass 13 g (12 %)other 5 g (5 %)

Cost by process

purchased $21.74 (47 %)cnc milling $16.50 (36 %)cnc turning $5.20 (11 %)stamping $1.77 (4 %)other $0.79 (2 %)

05Design for assembly

0DFA index %60

E = 3 × Nmin / T = 3 × 75 / 864 s = 26.1 %. Joints: press x27, screw x23, align x22, drop in x15, hold down x12, adhesive x12, snap x1. 23 fasteners.

Assembly time by line item

F01 Movement screws (bridges, cock144 sM19 Jewels pressed into plate and 135 sP02 Regulation on a timegrapher, d90 sP01 Lubrication points (oils and g72 sF02 Dial-side screws27 sM26 Date driving wheel, date jumpe26 sM22 Setting lever, yoke and yoke s26 sD03 Hands (hour, minute, seconds) 22 sM29 Pawl lever with eccentric and 18 sC10 Casing clamps with screws18 s

Parts that are not theoretically necessary

IDPartQtyTime
F01Movement screws (bridges, cock, rotor, plates)16144.0 s
P02Regulation on a timegrapher, demagnetise190.0 s
P01Lubrication points (oils and greases)1272.0 s
F02Dial-side screws327.0 s
C10Casing clamps with screws218.0 s
S02Spring bars217.0 s
C09Movement holder ring15.2 s

Boothroyd test: a part must stay separate only if it moves relative to the others, needs a different material, or must come apart for assembly or service.

06Should-cost

Parts $46.00 + assembly labour $1.44 = $47.44, 16 % of the $295.00 retail price. 16 of 49 line items make 80 % of parts cost.

C01 Case middle with lugs$9.00C04 Sapphire crystal, AR coated in$4.50S01 FKM rubber strap halves$4.00C06 Screw-down caseback$3.00M01 Main plate (pillar plate)$3.00C02 Unidirectional bezel with anod$2.20D01 Dial, printed, applied lumed i$2.00C08 Screw-down crown with tube and$1.60M02 Barrel bridge$1.20M28 Oscillating weight (rotor) on $1.20

Estimates from mass, indicative material prices, machine rates and amortised tooling (or given quotes). Use for ranking and comparison, not for quoting.

07Design decisions worth copying

A 1:5760 reduction in four meshes
Barrel 80/10, centre 64/8, third 75/10, fourth 84/7. The centre wheel turns once an hour, the fourth once a minute, the escape wheel 12 times a minute, and the barrel once every 8 h.
Every wheel has a job on the dial (hour, minute, seconds) or in the energy budget (8 h per barrel turn gives the 41 h reserve with about 5 spring turns). Pinions of 7-10 leaves keep the wheels small, at the cost of some engagement friction.
The pawl lever winds in both directions with two parts
An eccentric on the rotor pinion rocks a lever with two pawls that push the transmission wheel on both strokes.
Replaces a pair of reverser wheels (each a small clutch of 6-8 parts) and is more efficient at low rotor angles. It is also why this archetype is cheap and robust.
A slipping bridle instead of a stop
The outer end of the mainspring is a friction bridle against the barrel wall.
The automatic can never overwind: at full wind the bridle slips. One feature does the job of a separate torque limiter.
One brass plate locates everything
About 40 bored seats in the main plate hold jewels, pillars and steady pins; the bridges only cap them.
Holding the critical centre distances in one part is what makes the train mesh without fitting by hand. The plate costs more than any wheel because of it.
Water resistance lives in four rubber rings
Crystal, caseback and two crown gaskets are the only seals. The steel and the sapphire do no sealing on their own.
The 200 m rating is a maintenance item, not a property of the case. The rating depends on the cheapest parts in the watch.

08Repairability

0score / 1010
Wear / failure partHeld byParts removed firstScore
Sapphire crystal, AR coated insidepress16.1
Caseback gasketalign17.9
Screw-down crown with tube and 2 gasketsscrew08.2
Mainspring with slipping bridlehold down57.0
Oscillating weight (rotor) on ball bearingalign17.9
Balance wheel with staff, roller and impulse jewelalign16.5
FKM rubber strap halvesalign010.0

09Failure modes

APItemModeEffectCauseS/O/DRPNAction
HighCaseback and crown gasketsLose compression with age and sunscreenWater ingress, rust on the movementRubber compression set after 3-5 years8/4/6192FKM gaskets, pressure test at each service, print 'service every 5 years' in the manual
MediumLubricantsOil dries or migratesAmplitude drops, rate drifts, wear on pivotsOil ageing over 5-7 years; epilame missing on a jewel5/6/5150Epilame on escape and pallet jewels; dry-lubricated silicon escapement in a premium version
MediumHairspringMagnetised (coils stick)Gains minutes per dayLaptop speaker, phone case or bag clasp magnets6/5/4120Silicon or Nb-Zr hairspring; soft-iron inner cage as a lower-cost option
MediumBalance staff pivotsBreak on impactWatch stopsDrop onto a hard floor beyond the shock-setting travel7/3/242Check shock-spring preload; larger end-shake limits
LowDate mechanismJams when quick-set between 21:00 and 03:00Bent date jumper or broken date-driving toothQuickset fights the driving finger while it engages4/5/7140Slip clutch on the date driving wheel, or an instantaneous date jump
LowMainspringFatigue fractureWatch stops, no powerCyclic winding over about 10 years7/2/342Replace at service; spring is a stock part

10Benchmark

ProductRegulatorAccuracyPower reserveParts (movement)Service intervalTypical price
This watch (mass-market automatic)Balance + hairspring, 3 Hz-20/+40 s/day~41 h~1305-7 years$250-400
Typical quartz diverQuartz 32,768 Hz+/-15 s/monthBattery 2-3 years~40-60Battery + gaskets$80-200
Typical certified Swiss automaticBalance + hairspring, 4 Hz-4/+6 s/day~38-80 h~140-2005-10 years$1,000+

11Redesign opportunities

OpportunityChangeImpactEffortSaving / unit (negative = adds cost)
Size the movement to the caseBore the case middle to the movement diameter and delete the holder ringOne part and one assembly step fewer; the movement seats on metal, not plasticlow$0.05
Fold the pallet bridge into the train bridgeOne bridge carries the train and the pallet pivotsOne part and two screws fewer, about 15 s off assembly; the pallet still comes out with the train bridge for servicemed$0.55
Quick-release spring barsSpring bars with a lever so the wearer changes straps without a toolThe commonest owner repair becomes tool-free; strap sales riselow−$0.15
Silicon hairspringReplace the Fe-Ni hairspring with oxidised siliconRemoves the magnetism failure mode and improves temperature stability; needs a new collet and studhigh−$2.50
Date mechanism that cannot jamSlip clutch on the date driving wheelRemoves the 21:00-03:00 'do not set' warning from the manualmed−$0.10

Cost-down moves together: $0.60 per unit (1.3 % of should-cost; savings can overlap). Upgrades that add cost: $2.75 per unit.

12Engineering verdict

A textbook mass-market automatic: the gear train, pawl-lever winding and slipping bridle get the most function from the fewest parts, and the brass main plate does the precision work so that the wheels can be cheap. The cost sits in the case, the crystal and the plate rather than in the gears, and assembly is dominated by tiny-part handling, sixteen movement screws, lubrication and regulation. Reliability is set by the four gaskets, the oil and the hairspring's magnetism, not by the steel. A silicon hairspring and a jam-proof date are the upgrades that change the owner experience; the holder ring and the separate pallet bridge are the cost-downs.