mechanical-engineering-skills

Tutorial: MeltpoolNet (process parameters → melt-pool size and mode)

Skill: meltpool-geometry · Paper: P. Akbari, F. Ogoke, N.-Y. Kao, K. Meidani, C.-Y. Yeh, W. Lee, A. Barati Farimani, MeltpoolNet: Melt pool characteristic prediction in Metal Additive Manufacturing using machine learning, Additive Manufacturing 55 (2022) 102817, doi:10.1016/j.addma.2022.102817 · Data: BaratiLab/MeltpoolNet

MeltpoolNet collected melt-pool measurements from more than 80 metal AM papers: power, speed, beam size, alloy, and the resulting depth, width, length and melt-pool mode. It benchmarks ML models with physics-aware features and fits explicit power laws that respect dimensional analysis.

This skill gives you three estimators, from most interpretable to most data-driven:

  1. Rosenthal
  2. a fitted power law
  3. ML models

It also tests honestly how well the ML models transfer to a machine they have never seen.

Use cases

Setup

npx skills add BaratiLab/mechanical-engineering-skills --skill meltpool-geometry
pip install numpy pandas scipy scikit-learn matplotlib joblib
cd skills/meltpool-geometry

1. Physics first: Rosenthal

python scripts/meltpool.py rosenthal --material SS316L --power 200 --velocity 800

The result is depth 59 µm, width 118 µm and length 462 µm, with absorbed power 66 W (minimum absorptivity 0.33 from the data). Rosenthal assumes conduction mode, so it under-predicts keyhole depths.

2. An explicit formula from data

python scripts/meltpool.py identify --target depth

The fit is y = w0·P^a·V^b·ρ^c·Cp^d·k^e·(Tm−T0)^f with the four dimensional constraints (mass, length, time, temperature) solved exactly; the residuals print as zeros. Result on 1,340 depth measurements:

Exponent P V ρ Cp k ΔT
Fitted 0.51 −0.22 −0.49 −0.63 −0.02 −0.64

The P exponent sits right at Rosenthal’s ½.

Target Fitted power law R² Rosenthal R², same rows
depth 0.24 strongly negative
width 0.64 strongly negative
length 0.57 strongly negative

The paper reported 0.787, 0.991 and 0.473 for the power law. Its published equations don’t reproduce on today’s public CSV under any unit convention we tried. Report what you reproduce.

3. ML, and the question that matters: will it transfer?

python scripts/meltpool.py benchmark --target depth --features baseline,energy --split random --models gb --plot a.png
python scripts/meltpool.py benchmark --target depth --features baseline,energy --split paper  --models gb
python scripts/meltpool.py benchmark --target depth --features baseline,energy --split paper  --models gb --calibrate 10

Parity plots

Split Depth R² MAE
Random 5-fold, as in the paper 0.78 43 µm
Leave-paper-out (whole source studies held out) −0.10 98 µm
Leave-paper-out + 3 of your own tracks per study 0.52 71 µm
Leave-paper-out + 10 of your own tracks per study 0.70 54 µm

A random split shares machines, powders and measurement methods between train and test. A new machine looks like an unseen paper. The fix is cheap: measure a few single tracks and retrain with --extra.

Melt-pool mode classification follows the same pattern: 82.6% accuracy with a random split (the paper reports 85.8%) and about 45% leave-paper-out.

4. Predict, with the caveats attached

python scripts/meltpool.py train --target depth --features baseline,energy --model gb --out depth.joblib [--extra my_tracks.csv]
python scripts/meltpool.py train --target width --features baseline,energy --model gb --out width.joblib
python scripts/meltpool.py predict --models depth.joblib,width.joblib --material Ti-6Al-4V --power 250 --velocity 1000 --beam 80

For Ti-6Al-4V at 250 W and 1000 mm/s, the output is:

Notes

Cite: Akbari et al., Addit. Manuf. 55 (2022) 102817.